Italy vs United States: where is a cheap home better value?

On RealHunt, homes in Italy cost a median €1,000 per m², 36% less than in the United States (€1,570 per m²). Buying costs start at about 4% in Italy and 2% in the United States.

ItalyUnited States
Homes on RealHunt8862
Median price€85,000€214,900
Median price per m²€1,000€1,570
Cheapest home€12,000€65,428
Median score8286
Costs on top of the price4-15%2-5%
Can foreigners buy?Yes for EU citizens; non-EU buyers need reciprocity (US, UK, Canada, Australia qualify).Yes. There is no federal ban on foreigners buying homes, but about 30 states have added some limits, and Texas and Florida restrict buyers from certain countries such as China.
Yearly property taxIMU 0.4-1.06% on second homes (on cadastral value).Property tax is set locally and in 2024 averaged about 1.22% of value across the largest city in each state, from 0.30% in Honolulu to 3.02% in Detroit.
Tax on rental incomeOptional flat 'cedolare secca' on short lets: 21% for one property, 26% from the second.By default a non-resident pays 30% of gross rent (or a lower treaty rate), withheld at source, or can elect to treat the rent as business income and pay graduated rates on net income by filing Form 1040-NR and giving Form W-8ECI to the withholding agent.

Prices describe the homes on RealHunt, each checked by a person, not every home in each country. Rules and taxes: general information, not legal or tax advice.

Best homes in Italy

  1. €95,000 · Renovated stone house with a lake-view balcony above Lake Como · San Siro, Lake Como · score 91 · 60 m² · 2 bed
  2. €29,000 · Holiday flat with a big sea-view terrace and garden in Calabria · Torremezzo, Falconara Albanese, Calabria · score 91 · 55 m² · 1 bed
  3. €30,000 · Furnished seaside flat a few steps from the beach at Acqualadrone, Messina · Acqualadrone, Messina, Sicily · score 91 · 40 m² · 1 bed

All 88 homes in Italy · How to buy in Italy · Costs and sources

Best homes in the United States

  1. €82,875 · Move-in ready 2-bed house in Chapmanville, West Virginia · Chapmanville, West Virginia · score 95 · 176 m² · 2 bed
  2. €78,426 · Updated 3-bed house in Huntington, West Virginia · Huntington, West Virginia · score 95 · 150 m² · 3 bed
  3. €223,300 · Renovated 1889 Victorian with a deep front porch in Lynchburg, Virginia · Lynchburg, Virginia · score 93 · 289 m² · 3 bed

All 62 homes in the United States · How to buy in the United States · Costs and sources